This is a sample explanation showing the kind of help tutors give. It is not an answer from a specific tutor.
The explanation
Law problem questions give you a set of facts and ask what the legal outcome is. IRAC keeps your answer organised:
- Issue: the specific legal question raised by the facts.
- Rule: the relevant law, supported by authority (a case or statute).
- Application: apply the rule to these particular facts. This is where most of the marks are.
- Conclusion: answer the issue, even if you have to say which way it is likely to go.
Example facts: On Monday, Ann emails Ben offering to sell him her bike for $200, open until Friday. On Tuesday Ben replies, "I'll take it for $180." Ann doesn't answer. On Wednesday Ben emails, "Fine, I accept $200." Ann has already sold the bike to Cara. Does Ben have a contract with Ann?
Issue: whether Ben's Wednesday email accepted Ann's offer, or whether that offer had already ended.
Rule: acceptance must match the terms of the offer exactly (the mirror image rule). A reply that changes the terms is a counter-offer, which rejects and ends the original offer, so it cannot be accepted later: Hyde v Wrench (1840).
Application: Ann's offer was to sell for $200. Ben's Tuesday reply changed the price to $180, a key term, so it was a counter-offer rather than an acceptance. Under Hyde v Wrench, that counter-offer ended Ann's offer. Although Ann had said the offer was open until Friday, there was no longer an offer for Ben to accept on Wednesday. His "Fine, I accept $200" was at most a new offer, which Ann was free to refuse, and she did not accept it.
Conclusion: there is no contract between Ann and Ben, so Ann was free to sell the bike to Cara.
What makes a strong IRAC answer:
- One IRAC per issue. Many questions hide several issues. Deal with each separately.
- Use the facts. Weak answers state the rule and jump to a conclusion. Strong ones show exactly which fact triggers which part of the rule.
- Argue both sides when the law is unclear, then say which view is stronger and why.
- Cite authority for every rule.
Your course may use a variation such as ILAC, IPAC or CREAC; the logic is the same. This is study help for coursework, not legal advice, and the law differs between jurisdictions.
Up against a deadline? Next time you're stuck on law homework and short on time, post it on HomeworkHero with your deadline. There's no posting fee, you compare offers from tutors and choose who to work with, and your payment is held in escrow until you approve the work.
Topics
- irac
- problem questions
- contract law
- offer and acceptance
- law