This is a sample explanation showing the kind of help tutors give. It is not an answer from a specific tutor.
The explanation
Negligence is the most commonly examined tort. A claimant must prove all four elements; if one fails, the whole claim fails.
1. Duty of care
Did the defendant owe the claimant a legal duty to take care? The foundation is Lord Atkin's "neighbour principle" in Donoghue v Stevenson (1932): you must take reasonable care to avoid acts or omissions you can reasonably foresee would injure people closely and directly affected by them. Many relationships already have an established duty, such as driver and road user, doctor and patient, and occupier and visitor.
2. Breach of duty
Did the defendant fall below the standard of care expected? The test is objective: what would a reasonable person in the defendant's position have done? Courts weigh factors such as how likely the harm was, how serious it would be, the cost of precautions and the social value of the activity. Professionals are judged against a reasonable member of their profession.
3. Causation
- Factual causation (the "but for" test): but for the defendant's breach, would the harm have happened? If it would have happened anyway, there is no causation.
- Legal causation (remoteness): was the type of harm reasonably foreseeable? The defendant is not liable for harm of an unforeseeable kind, and an unforeseeable intervening act can break the chain of causation.
4. Damage
The claimant must have suffered damage the law recognises, such as personal injury or damage to property. Carelessness alone, with no harm, is not enough.
Applying the elements to an example: A supermarket employee spills cooking oil in an aisle and leaves it unmarked for an hour. A customer slips and breaks her wrist.
- Duty: an occupier owes visitors a duty of care. ✓
- Breach: a reasonable supermarket would clean up or mark a spill within a short time; leaving it for an hour falls below that standard. ✓
- Causation: but for the unmarked spill she would not have slipped, and a slip injury is exactly the kind of harm a spill makes foreseeable. ✓
- Damage: a broken wrist is personal injury. ✓
- Conclusion: the supermarket is likely to be liable. Then consider defences, such as contributory negligence if she was running or looking at her phone, which could reduce her damages.
Exam tips: take the elements in order, give authority for each, and spend most of your time on the element the facts make doubtful. Details differ between jurisdictions, and some have statutes covering areas such as occupiers' liability, so follow the law your course teaches. This is study help, not legal advice.
Up against a deadline? Next time you're stuck on law homework and short on time, post it on HomeworkHero with your deadline. There's no posting fee, you compare offers from tutors and choose who to work with, and your payment is held in escrow until you approve the work.
Topics
- negligence
- tort law
- duty of care
- causation
- law