This is a sample explanation showing the kind of help tutors give. It is not an answer from a specific tutor.
The explanation
A case brief is a short summary of a judgment in a fixed structure. It forces you to pull out what matters, and it is what you will revise from before exams.
The sections of a brief:
- Citation: the case name, year and court.
- Facts: only the facts that mattered to the decision.
- Procedural history: how the case reached this court and who appealed.
- Issue: the legal question the court had to answer, ideally as a yes or no question.
- Holding: the court's answer to the issue.
- Reasoning: why the court decided that way.
- Rule: the legal principle the case stands for, which you will cite in future answers.
- Dissent (if any): the main argument of the judges who disagreed.
Example brief: Donoghue v Stevenson [1932] AC 562 (House of Lords)
- Facts: Mrs Donoghue's friend bought her a bottle of ginger beer at a café in Paisley, Scotland. The bottle was opaque. After drinking some, she poured out the rest and allegedly found a decomposed snail. She claimed she suffered shock and gastroenteritis. She had no contract with the café or the manufacturer, Stevenson, because her friend paid.
- Procedural history: she sued the manufacturer. The question of whether her claim could succeed in law, assuming the facts were true, was appealed from the Scottish Court of Session to the House of Lords.
- Issue: does a manufacturer owe a duty of care to the ultimate consumer of its product, even without a contract between them?
- Holding: yes, by a 3 to 2 majority.
- Reasoning: Lord Atkin reasoned that you must take reasonable care to avoid acts or omissions you can reasonably foresee would injure your "neighbour": people so closely and directly affected that you ought to have them in mind. A manufacturer of goods sold in a form the consumer cannot inspect, like an opaque bottle, should have the consumer in mind.
- Rule: a manufacturer owes a duty of care to the ultimate consumer where the product reaches them with no reasonable chance of intermediate inspection. More broadly, the neighbour principle became the foundation of the modern law of negligence.
- Dissent: the minority held that a manufacturer's duty to people it had no contract with should stay limited to dangerous goods and existing categories.
Tips:
- Write it in your own words. Copying the judgment doesn't show you understood it.
- Keep it to a page. A brief is a tool for revision, not a transcript.
- Separate the holding from the reasoning. The holding answers the issue; the reasoning explains it.
- Note the rule precisely. That is the part you will reuse in problem questions.
This is study help for coursework, not legal advice.
Up against a deadline? Next time you're stuck on law homework and short on time, post it on HomeworkHero with your deadline. There's no posting fee, you compare offers from tutors and choose who to work with, and your payment is held in escrow until you approve the work.
Topics
- case brief
- legal research
- donoghue v stevenson
- negligence
- law